Fire Death in Philadelphia:Smoke Detectors the only answer?

On February 24th, 2013 at around 11:30 PM  Firefighters from the city of Philadelphia responded to an alarm in the Southwest part of the city.  They were met with heavy fire showing on the first floor of a row home.  As always they acted quickly to douse the flames and save anyone inside.  Tragically one man on the second floor died in the fire and two escaped with injuries.  Fire Commissioner Lloyd Ayers took to the airwaves to tell the story and predictably he came up with the most obvious answer.

If there had been smoke detectors this man would be alive today.  Bravo Commissioner for stating the obvious.  But what about the cause of the fire.  Before you can claim that a working smoke detector could have saved a life there were so many other factors that led up to this tragedy.

The home had been divided up into five separate apartments, described in the news video from NBC 10 as a boarding house. Was this compartmentalization legally done? If there a record of this being an apartment building?  Remember that potentially five or more people could have roomed here. The owner of this building also let the heater, which according to the news reports was an oil heater, stop working.  Another negative to the situation.

As reported by the news the electrical box was “a mess”.  So what we may have here is an overloaded electrical service device bought on by the renters having to use portable electric heaters.  Just one heater requires a 15 Amp breaker.  If all five tenants had one heater we are talking 75% of the total load on a 100 Amp box.  Unless this home was upgraded to a larger box to accommodate the multiple tenants the die was cast long before  the failure to put smoke detectors in each unit.

To make matters worse the Smoke detector system (actually Fire Detection) in an apartment building is required to be integrated to alert all residence.  Individual smoke alarms would not be enough or legal.

The Fire Commissioner should be talking about ensuring proper living conditions for residents and quit blaming the lack of smoke detectors.  The problems of the poor in the city go way beyond the presence of a device.

Eight fire deaths this year already.  The city is on it’s way to 48.  That would be tragic as is each untimely fire death.



Filed under Philadelphia Fire Department

3 responses to “Fire Death in Philadelphia:Smoke Detectors the only answer?

  1. Mayor Nutter and the City of Philadelphia are a disgrace city, The Streets Department can damage your property and they want you to turn into your insurance company instead of them paying for it. The City of Philadelphia sucks.

  2. Mike Wellock

    Having made the job, I cannot confirm nor deny whether a smoke detector was in the fire dwelling. I have no personal knowledge of one. But 2 of the members of my company said they heard a detector (in the fire dwelling) while performing overhaul operations.
    Possible it was not going off upon entry, but at least “two” FFers reported hearing one.
    Would have to talk with a few more people who made the ‘job’ to confirm.
    Detectors are a tool. They do not make rescues and they do not extinguish fire.

    • The Working Class Conservative

      Would you say the configuration would preclude one or more persons from possibly hearing it? Especially since your guys did not until overhaul? The root of the issue is code and it was not up to it. Sad for the residents

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s